10 Oct 2013 11:06 AM #71
"bug fixes for money".-->
10 Oct 2013 11:07 AM #72
Here's our list of failed release show stoppers. We haven't upgraded since August 2012. Some only on IE 8 others cross browser. I'm questioning the wisdom of continuing to put our resources into EXTJS.
extjs 4.1.2 - currently in production
extjs 4.1.3 - dynamically created accordion panel has all panels uncollapsed
extjs 4.2.0 - SSL alert for IE 8 on every page refresh
extjs 4.2.1 - Could only activate a menu by clicking on its text, not the blank area around it
extjs 4.2.2 - getEditor() method is missing from column class - still testing this though but works in 4.1.2
extjs 4.2.3 - ??????-->
10 Oct 2013 4:24 PM #73
It feels like a hacker's framework, as long as you can hunt through the internals, it can be made to work. I loved doing that in 3.x but can no longer afford to do that anymore. My clients need new features, they do not pay me to work on the framework to fix issues.
Perhaps ExtJS is good for corporate licenses or partners, but its pretty frustating for individual developers. I would pay good money for a UI framework without the shenanigans of paywalled bug fixes and minor release breaking changes. Seriously, has the Sencha team even tried to look from the point of view of individual developers?-->
11 Oct 2013 12:04 AM #74
I'm totally sure that Sencha developers are quality developers (Don, Nige, Evan, etc.), it is self-evident that this is not the point, even if I should also say that Sencha has lost some really good developers (like Ed and others, this is really bad).
As pointed before, the real point is that we are sayng that Sencha is losing many community quality developers and it is obvious that you can't do all the job inside Sencha but you need Community to go on, who can disagree?
Some weeks ago I was so frustated with bugs with Ext.data module that I spent all the day (more than 8 hours of work by a senior developer) debugging your code, hacking internals as said by @sumit.madan, in only one day I did full report (with description, source code, example, etc.) of 4 verified and classified bugs (you can dig bug forum to verify). Then I realized that at 90% I'll not receive the bugfixed version, I double checked this because I could not believe that Sencha will not share bugfix with me, a community developer who reported the bug!
After that, I decided to make my patches on my own, and I will not report any bug until Sencha changes this absurd politic. I'm sure that many other developers did the same decision, as we can read on this thread, and I think that it is quite obvious that for this reason ExtJS 4 is slowing down. By my experience, if Sencha does not change its mind, it will be soon passed over by some other framework (worse than ExtJS) but more community-friendly.
If I spend time writing down here, it is because I like ExtJS and Sencha and I'm worried about, and I think that @mitchellsimoens should not reply with his questionable sentences.
I like @LisburnLad proposal but I think it is quite difficult to become real.-->
11 Oct 2013 6:50 AM #75
This is the first time I've tried to download a support-only version of ExtJS in a few years (4.2.2), and I'm having some troubles. I'd like to be able to download it directly to by server (via wget), but it appears I can't do that unless I'm actually "logged in" to support.sencha.com. Is there any way to do this from my server? I can download it locally, but I'd rather not need to upload a 65MB file from my computer to my server over my fairly slow internet.
(Also, after many minutes of searching on sencha.com, I was unable to find a link to the Support area. Only after remembering the URL was probably support.sencha.com was I able to log into it and even find the link to 4.2.2.)
I realize that Sencha's trying to lock non-paying users out of 4.2.2 (and I'll totally stay out of that discussion for now), but I really wish they didn't make it such a pain for paying customers to get it too.-->
16 Oct 2013 8:46 AM #76
Is Sencha waiting while this thread will be rated out? No comments from them at all...-->
16 Oct 2013 10:26 AM #77
You should have looked harder.
Sencha employees have been actively responding to this thread and the many others like it. What usually ends up happening, however, is that the discussion stops being about productive criticism and starts being about complaining and ranting. There's nothing Sencha can say at that point, so it's better for everyone to just let that "conversation" wind down on its own.
If anyone wants their concerns to be heard in official capacity (not to say the forums aren't official), there's a perfectly good Contact Form for just this purpose.-->
16 Oct 2013 12:08 PM #78
This thread served the purpose of inquiring the progress of 4.2.2. Now as 4.2.2 has been rolled out, I think further discussions started to be off topic. I understand there are a lot of things we can talk about Extjs, however, I would suggest they will be discussed in separate and more relevant threads. Therefore I will close this thread as the purpose of this thread, as the subject suggested, has been met now.
Finally I would like to appreciate the great efforts by Sencha developers to roll out the usable version of 4.2.2.
Thread Participants: 31
- mitchellsimoens (7 Posts)
- andong (1 Post)
- mcouillard (2 Posts)
- qooleot (1 Post)
- lombardo (1 Post)
- christophe.geiser (2 Posts)
- LisburnLad (2 Posts)
- firefoxSafari (2 Posts)
- AlexKorn (1 Post)
- sumit.madan (5 Posts)
- op1op (1 Post)
- aw1zard2 (5 Posts)
- dougbieber (1 Post)
- nailuo (1 Post)
- olegtaranenko (3 Posts)
- LesJ (1 Post)
- sblommers (10 Posts)
- fdp (5 Posts)
- frm (2 Posts)
- eric.cook (1 Post)
- Qarea (1 Post)
- blomasky (1 Post)
- Misiu (5 Posts)
- benjamineberle (1 Post)
- jkyoutsey (1 Post)
- terezka (1 Post)
- email@example.com (1 Post)
- Gary Schlosberg (4 Posts)
- chocis (1 Post)
- addama (1 Post)
- m.dostal (1 Post)