1. #751
    Ext JS Premium Member Lloyd K's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    Brighton, United Kingdom
    Posts
    655
    Vote Rating
    1
    Lloyd K is on a distinguished road

      0  

    Default


    Ahh that's good then, phew, don't want ANOTHER license change :P
    -->

  2. #752
    Sencha User sb32's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Posts
    66
    Vote Rating
    0
    sb32 is on a distinguished road

      0  

    Default


    At first glance, this sounds promising. I just hope it means what I think it does.
    -->

  3. #753
    Sencha User jack.slocum's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Tampa, FL
    Posts
    6,955
    Vote Rating
    16
    jack.slocum will become famous soon enough

      0  

    Default


    I just want to confirm that this is indeed a lite base library that is being released under MIT, not Ext JS. The license for Ext JS will not be changing and we have no plans to change its license in the future.
    Jack Slocum
    Ext JS Founder
    Original author of Ext JS 1, 2 & 3.
    Twitter: @jackslocum
    jack@extjs.com
    -->

  4. #754
    Ext User
    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Posts
    6
    Vote Rating
    0
    Martin Kraus is an unknown quantity at this point

      0  

    Default


    Jack - I am going to ask the obvious questions - which I am sure most of the users are thinking about

    1. What's the rationale between releasing a MIT licensed library. You went down that path with yui-ext and said that people were "stealing" your working and not giving you due credit which is how you justified the change in the license.

    2. Why should users trust that you will not gradually change the base library to lgpl and then to gpl after enough users start using it.

    Thanks,

    Kraus
    -->

  5. #755
    Sencha User jack.slocum's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Tampa, FL
    Posts
    6,955
    Vote Rating
    16
    jack.slocum will become famous soon enough

      0  

    Default


    1. Contrary to popular belief, we do enjoy giving back to the JS open source community. Core parts of yui-ext (e.g. DomQuery and DomHelper code) are still used in other libraries today. Most core JS libraries are under very permissive licenses, and we think ours should be as well.

    2. I have already explained why Ext's license was changed to GPL several times. I am sure you have read it. There would be no reason why a base library would need the same license change since it would start with an MIT license, not an "almost open source" license. If you are instead trying to insinuate a "bait and switch", I am not going to legitimize such a question by giving a response.
    Jack Slocum
    Ext JS Founder
    Original author of Ext JS 1, 2 & 3.
    Twitter: @jackslocum
    jack@extjs.com
    -->

  6. #756
    Sencha User
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Posts
    7,854
    Vote Rating
    4
    tryanDLS is on a distinguished road

      0  

    Default


    Jack,

    In #1 above, you mention both DomQuery and DomHelper. Looking at the 2.2 files, DomQuery includes the MIT license statement, but DomHelper does not. Will the new lite library contain an MIT version of DomHelper functionality or will DomHelper itself be changed to state MIT or does it maintain the normal license?
    -->

  7. #757
    Sencha User jack.slocum's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Tampa, FL
    Posts
    6,955
    Vote Rating
    16
    jack.slocum will become famous soon enough

      0  

    Default


    Tim, the new core lib itself will entirely be MIT. DomHelper was originally created back in the yui-ext days, so people used the BSD licensed version.
    Jack Slocum
    Ext JS Founder
    Original author of Ext JS 1, 2 & 3.
    Twitter: @jackslocum
    jack@extjs.com
    -->

  8. #758
    Ext User
    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Posts
    12
    Vote Rating
    0
    superman2008 is on a distinguished road

      0  

    Default


    hi, i want ask question about license, i use extjs to get data from server, this code on server will go GPL as well?
    -->

  9. #759
    Sencha User
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Posts
    7,854
    Vote Rating
    4
    tryanDLS is on a distinguished road

      0  

    Default


    @superman - these type of questions have been discussed in some detail in the multiple license threads here and also in the license faq. If your specific question is not answered by any of them, please send your question to licensing@extjs.com
    -->

Thread Participants: 176

  1. jack.slocum (31 Posts)
  2. JeffHowden (6 Posts)
  3. TommyMaintz (5 Posts)
  4. kellysz (2 Posts)
  5. tryanDLS (2 Posts)
  6. christocracy (9 Posts)
  7. jay@moduscreate.com (9 Posts)
  8. vtswingkid (1 Post)
  9. willgillen (2 Posts)
  10. yogurtearl (1 Post)
  11. buzz (1 Post)
  12. bidyut (1 Post)
  13. jason (1 Post)
  14. adrian.tarau (14 Posts)
  15. tbenbrahim (3 Posts)
  16. vmorale4 (13 Posts)
  17. tierneyja (2 Posts)
  18. DaNCeT (1 Post)
  19. Preston (2 Posts)
  20. stever (1 Post)
  21. PuritysDisciple (1 Post)
  22. stucco (3 Posts)
  23. Jul (1 Post)
  24. dj (13 Posts)
  25. ReyBango (1 Post)
  26. dolittle (1 Post)
  27. mystix (5 Posts)
  28. stekolla (1 Post)
  29. JoeK (2 Posts)
  30. albeva (1 Post)
  31. bloudon (2 Posts)
  32. shanebush (2 Posts)
  33. dantheman (21 Posts)
  34. mberkay (1 Post)
  35. jheid (3 Posts)
  36. jsakalos (1 Post)
  37. rashadmoore (1 Post)
  38. bitdifferent (1 Post)
  39. FlexIDX (15 Posts)
  40. kpandey (1 Post)
  41. acharis (5 Posts)
  42. pabs (8 Posts)
  43. DigitalSkyline (12 Posts)
  44. Darklight (2 Posts)
  45. evant (8 Posts)
  46. Illiarian (2 Posts)
  47. seymores (5 Posts)
  48. HartlepoolLad (4 Posts)
  49. Rowan (1 Post)
  50. jexxi (1 Post)
  51. J.C. Bize (4 Posts)
  52. mschering (1 Post)
  53. antimatter15 (2 Posts)
  54. kris (2 Posts)
  55. mdm-adph (1 Post)
  56. patspam (7 Posts)
  57. ethraza (3 Posts)
  58. Tim Siney (4 Posts)
  59. majorpay (22 Posts)
  60. niemeyer (1 Post)
  61. crafter (4 Posts)
  62. Chris in Cambridge (3 Posts)
  63. ftftft (1 Post)
  64. FXetc (2 Posts)
  65. seade (9 Posts)
  66. esoteric (38 Posts)
  67. xtrafile (1 Post)
  68. esra (3 Posts)
  69. rednix (5 Posts)
  70. Zyclops (1 Post)
  71. pyrolupus (1 Post)
  72. hendricd (2 Posts)
  73. joeri (2 Posts)
  74. djfiii (6 Posts)
  75. kw (1 Post)
  76. mscdex (3 Posts)
  77. philmaker (1 Post)
  78. perler (2 Posts)
  79. DragonFist (1 Post)
  80. robinet (1 Post)
  81. sb32 (1 Post)
  82. ziesemer (24 Posts)
  83. ThorstenSuckow (8 Posts)
  84. jerrybrown5 (3 Posts)
  85. mykes (1 Post)
  86. Geoff (2 Posts)
  87. improva (3 Posts)
  88. Lloyd K (7 Posts)
  89. rtconner (1 Post)
  90. Lobos (13 Posts)
  91. durlabh (5 Posts)
  92. fernandoferreira (7 Posts)
  93. mabello (2 Posts)
  94. sigaref (1 Post)
  95. mankz (1 Post)
  96. random0xff (1 Post)
  97. ArSa (2 Posts)
  98. randygo (3 Posts)
  99. Rocco (2 Posts)
  100. jdupont092 (13 Posts)
  101. bear330 (1 Post)
  102. SeaSharp2 (6 Posts)
  103. Dig (9 Posts)
  104. hotnuts21 (1 Post)
  105. s.kerroumi (8 Posts)
  106. franck34 (1 Post)
  107. figital (1 Post)
  108. retrogradeorbit (1 Post)
  109. OutpostMM (21 Posts)
  110. SAnDAnGE (1 Post)
  111. Richo99 (8 Posts)
  112. irongaze (4 Posts)
  113. herrjj (1 Post)
  114. wrhighfield (3 Posts)
  115. xpurpur (1 Post)
  116. jaxl (1 Post)
  117. hardrock (4 Posts)
  118. Rich Kucera (2 Posts)
  119. ibrandt (2 Posts)
  120. rainydays (2 Posts)
  121. jergarmar (1 Post)
  122. fullej (1 Post)
  123. dotchris (7 Posts)
  124. benb (19 Posts)
  125. erictang (1 Post)
  126. enpasos (1 Post)
  127. dynqnet (6 Posts)
  128. sgodden (1 Post)
  129. Etienne Lacazedieu (1 Post)
  130. Arthur.Blake (5 Posts)
  131. MarcWeil (2 Posts)
  132. timsporcic (1 Post)
  133. j_johnso (2 Posts)
  134. asanjum (1 Post)
  135. BernieM (2 Posts)
  136. kekoav (4 Posts)
  137. ds (1 Post)
  138. NoahK17 (6 Posts)
  139. rule3 (8 Posts)
  140. zarembisty (6 Posts)
  141. gregphoto (1 Post)
  142. dezo33 (22 Posts)
  143. grom358 (15 Posts)
  144. lemonade (6 Posts)
  145. Martin Kraus (1 Post)
  146. raafoo (2 Posts)
  147. OSSCurious (1 Post)
  148. huherto (1 Post)
  149. Kutu (1 Post)
  150. jpnet (1 Post)
  151. LGPLman (2 Posts)
  152. mrsinister (1 Post)
  153. Insane.Kangaroo (17 Posts)
  154. outworlder (2 Posts)
  155. cherngje (4 Posts)
  156. lxmod (2 Posts)
  157. angbob (1 Post)
  158. scroisier (1 Post)
  159. scubajoe88 (2 Posts)
  160. pavera (12 Posts)
  161. PGTaboada (16 Posts)
  162. zaccret (4 Posts)
  163. Spoom (1 Post)
  164. markc (1 Post)
  165. ElGuapo (1 Post)
  166. ExtRocks (1 Post)
  167. blpiko (1 Post)
  168. Ext J$ (2 Posts)
  169. andrewroth (2 Posts)
  170. klyphio (1 Post)
  171. qbvbsite (4 Posts)
  172. NullDaddy (1 Post)
  173. deeep (1 Post)
  174. Chris503 (1 Post)
  175. superman2008 (1 Post)
  176. brian.moeskau (2 Posts)